If you need a player to come up big in a certain situation, Jack Mustaro is your man. The Westville native was an absolute beast on the basketball court, as he scored nearly 700 points as a senior while hitting 77 three-pointers in 28 games. He finished his career as the school’s all-time leading scorer with more than 1,800 points and he also had 399 rebounds, 145 steals and hit 265 threes.
On the baseball diamond, Mustaro, the younger brother of Rowan College of South Jersey-Gloucester standout R.J. Mustaro, was just as good. The 6-foot-2, 195-pound first baseman and pitcher hit .457 with 27 RBIs and led Gloucester Catholic to another state championship. He hit .387 for his career, and as a pitcher he owned a 0.47 ERA in 44 innings over two full seasons.