By MARY OVES
Correspondent
So it would seem that Ocean City has Sister Mary Margaret Cribben to thank. Karen Mahar was an undergraduate Communications major in Sister Mary Margaret Cribben’s Kiddie Lit course at Villanova, and she and Sister Cribben became close. Even so, Mahar was surprised in the summer of 1986 to hear from her.
“She told me, ‘We have a graduate assistantship in the Library Science department to get your master’s for free — come back to Villanova, we’ll pay you. Get your master’s in Library Science,’” Mahar recalls.
Mahar remembers discussing this incredible offer with her father, over dinner at Spadafora’s, on Labor Day weekend in 1986. As she recalls, she wasn’t sure what she wanted to do in the fall, but she remembers very clearly her father’s advice.
“He told me to get on the phone and accept that offer,” she said, “get your free master’s at Villanova, who would pass that up?”
“So I went, and when I finished, I did internships up there. Deciding to get my Master’s in Library Science did me very well.”
And it also taught Mahar an important lesson that she now imparts to her sons, Tommy and Victor, and daughter Millie.
“Make connections in life, be kind and open, be a good person,” she said. “Talk to people. You never know if the people you meet will be a connection that will help you throughout your life.”
Mahar is Library Director of the Ocean City Public Library, but that is just one of her many titles. As she rattles off her many community posts, even she seems amused at how much she actually manages to seize in a day. She is on the Board for Literacy Volunteers Association Cape/Atlantic, on the Board for the Ocean City Pops, is a member of the Miss New Jersey Education Foundation, is the Director for the Miss New Jersey parade, is on the Board of Directors for the Ocean City Chamber of Commerce — not to mention helping out in whatever capacity she can in sports and booster clubs.

Karen Mahar, director of the Ocean City Free Public Library, has three children, the youngest of whom, Millie, is set to begin her sophomore year at Ocean City High School. (Glory Days Magazine photo/Dave O’Sullivan)


“Peanut butter sandwiches, cases of water and Gatorade, whatever they needed,” she quipped.
In 2017, Mahar also won the prestigious Ocean City Chamber of Commerce Woman of the Year award, but even that title cannot surpass the significance of the title of which she is most proud: that of mom. Mom to Tommy, a junior at the University of Tampa. Mom to Victor, a freshman at Farleigh Dickinson. And mom to Millie, an incoming sophomore at Ocean City High School. Her children, along with her mother “G-Mom” (who lives with Mahar and whom she calls her best friend, a “feisty spit-fire,”) and her extended close-knit family all over the island serve to keep her grounded in love and faith.
“If it weren’t for my faith and my family, I might be living on an island alone somewhere. Which might not be a bad thing,” she joked.
Mahar has lived in Ocean City since the age of 4.
“I moved to Ocean City in 1969 when I was 4 years old. My parents bought a business and made it Tom’s Deli,” Mahar said. “I went to Ocean City schools until eighth grade and then went to Our Lady of Mercy Academy in Newfield for high school.”
Tom’s Deli is where she met her future husband, Jim, when he came in as a customer on a day she was working. She remembers it was April Fool’s Day, and says it was quite romantic.
“Jim came into the deli with his roommate, Johnny, who was a regular in the deli. Johnny was getting married that day, and Jim was in the wedding,” Mahar said. “Johnny introduced me to Jim, and when Jim was checking out, he bought a bag of Herr’s cheese popcorn. I was just making conversation and I just said, ‘Oh, is this cheese popcorn good?’”
Jim told Karen that it wasn’t as good as Smartfood popcorn in the black bag. The two men sat down, ate and left. Which might have been the end of the story. But it wasn’t.
“About twenty minutes later, Jim came back with about five bags of Smartfood popcorn and said ‘Here, I thought you might want to try this,’ and he gave them to me,” she recalled. “I opened a bag and we ate some of it. He left the deli to get to his wedding.’”
Karen’s father had been watching this whole exchange, and decided not to let an opportunity pass him by.

Karen’s middle child, Victor, played three years of football at St. Augustine Prep before transferring to Ocean City for his senior year, and now is playing college football. (Glory Days Magazine photo/Dave O’Sullivan)


“He said, ‘Give me that, you’re never going to eat all of that popcorn,’ and he put it on the shelf for sale. We have laughed about that ever since. It was typical of my father to not waste money, and typical of Jim to buy so many bags.”
Jim’s generosity must have worked, because it resulted in a loving marriage and three wonderful children. But Karen has been raising her three children alone since June 19, 2011, when Jim died of a massive heart attack on Father’s Day. She attributes her children’s successes to her husband.
“My kids are incredible,” she said. “They have turned their father’s death into motivation, and they’re trying to become what their father wanted them to become. It’s a lovely tribute to him.”
Mahar discusses her children, and their busy lives. It’s Tommy’s first year in an apartment at the University of Tampa, and he has changed his major to journalism. Victor has just been dropped off for his freshman year of college, and is looking forward to playing on the Farleigh Dickinson football team and majoring in finance. Millie, being the youngest, is being given a fair amount of freedom by mom Karen to pursue whatever it is she would like to.
“Her full name is Carmella, after my grandmother,” Mahar said. “She is a good, solid young lady, who can be sassy at times. She might play tennis in the spring, might manage the JV football team. She’s just figuring herself out, what she likes to do.”
With pictures of her children and late husband prominently displayed in her office, Karen remarks on her good fortune, her success and her happiness living in Ocean City.
“I have great kids, I had a great marriage. I’m lucky.”